Some of these names are of particular interest. AG Howarth (violin) became Sir
AG Howarth and was Chairman of the Hall
é Orchestra in the 1950s and 1960s. Frank Park played viola in the Hallé, and Miss Stancliffe (flute) was the sister of Patricia Stancliffe who played
cor anglais in the Hall
é both before and during the Barbirolli years. Rev EA Voysey (cello) was
father-in-law of the Manchester-born actor Robert Donat (1905-1958) who starred
in many films, including the huge hit The Thirty-Nine Steps (1935).
Evelyn Clayton, a childhood friend of Philip Godlee's wife Barbara, has written
a fascinating account of those pre-war days:
'One of the first musical activities I joined when we went to live in
Manchester, was the Alderley Edge Orchestra. It was at Philip's instigation. "I
wish you'd play in the orchestra," he said, "we have very good fun." This was
true. It was "very good fun," and the inspiration for the fun and the music
came from him.
'It was a curious mixture, like all amateur orchestras. But, unlike many, it was
properly run. There was a fixed practice night which Philip, as conductor,
never missed. I cannot remember a single time when he sent a deputy , although
he was a busy man, and must have had to make some sacrifices. There was a
subscription. There was a secretary and a treasurer and properly audited
accounts. Music was allowed to be borrowed, but is it was kept too long - and
only those who lend music know how conscious less people are in this respect -
Philip used to drive round in his car and make a personal call.
'There was a standard both of playing and of attendance. Philip was kindness
itself to those who tried hard, even if they couldn't play. I used to write out
carefully edited parts which were up to their technique - or lack of it. If
more conductors of amateur bands did this, we should not hear the sounds we do
at competition festivals. But he was adamant on dynamics and on careful
playing. "Dogs' bodies! " he used to shout. "Even if you can't play the notes,
you can play softly - and much better, too if you do". And there were one or
two scrapers he wouldn't have in, not because they couldn't play, but because
they wouldn't try.
'The reason for the excellence of the orchestra - and it was exceedingly good -
was this firm basis. Also, of course, he did have some very good players which
made the whole. The Bythell family, which supplied two excellent 'cellos and a
superlative violin, also added to the keenness and zest for they, too, never
missed. And there was the priceless blessing of a double bass who really could
play and who understood the music through and through. This was Olga Scott, who
was a rock and a tower of strength whether she played the bass or became a
'cello, which was her real instrument. George Lancashire cheerfully drove over
from Didsbury , wet or fine - or through fog - to play in the second violins,
because he so loved the atmosphere of music and gaiety.
'I remember playing in the "St Paul's" Suite of Gustav Holst, then not so well
known as it is now, and the enthusiasm of the audience. Philip confessed to the
orchestra afterwards, that once having given it its head in the last movement
he had moments when he wasn't sure that he could control it, if anything
untoward happened. But nothing upsetting did happen. We just went rollicking
along to the end with Philip looking gay and assured, and the final run-up and
crashing cord were a triumph. We were playing in the Alderley Edge Festival*,
and we won.
'It would be a one-sided picture of the orchestra if only its triumphs were
recorded. I remember the absolute failure. This was another Alderley Edge
Festival. We attempted a rather ambitious Handel concert**, and everything went
wrong. After a shaky start, we seemed unable to pull ourselves together and, in
spite of Philip's coaching produced more wrong entries than we had in all the
rehearsals put together. We wailed ourselves to an inglorious conclusion. I
ventured a timid glance at Philip, and was amazed to see that he was shaking
with uncontrollable laughter. He said afterwards that everything seemed to
"come on us" at once, and the only thing to do was to just to try hard, battle
on, and call it a day.
'This light heartedness restored the morale of the orchestra in miraculous
fashion, and our next performance was as assured and smooth running as the last
one disastrous.
'I do not know what happened to the orchestra - obviously it could not continue
during the war. And now it will never function again, or if it does, it will
have a tradition for an inspiration.'
*In 1928
**Concerto Grosso No 11 in B flat (arr. Esposito), performed at the 1933
Festival
But after the war, the Orchestra did indeed function again, and the recent
re-emergence of its first post-war minute book, after years in storage, gives a
fascinating insight into its early post-war months.
The Orchestra was re-established in its present form in 1952. A preliminary
Committee met on 12th June under the chaimanship of Mrs V M Shawcross and
agreed, after a discussion
‘at some length’ that the new organisation should be known as ‘The Alderley Edge Orchestral Society’ with the intention of giving an inaugural concert at the end of October or
early November.
It was agreed that rehearsals would take place at the Belmont Mission Hall in
Heyes Lane, premises then owned by the Wesleyan Methodist Church; the building
still exists, although it has in recent years been converted into private
dwellings.
The first formal committee meeting, chaired by Mr T Anderson and with Mrs
Shawcross as Treasurer and Miss M A Francis as Secretary, took place a
fortnight later on 30th June at Miss Francis
’s home at 28 Carrwood Road, Wilmslow. It was decided that the annual
subscription should be
£1. 1. 0d [£1.05 in today’s terms] and that those attending rehearsals (on Thursday evenings, as today)
would be charged 3d [just over 1p] for tea and biscuits. Philip Godlee was
invited to be the Society
’s first President, in recognition of his pre-war musical activities.
The major item of discussion, as might be expected, was the programme for the
first concert. This again was discussed
‘at some length’ and in keeping with the concert planning traditions of the day the Committee
finally agreed the generous, if somewhat indigestible, offering of:
Magic Flute Overture [Mozart]
Chanson de Matin [Elgar]
Chanson de Nuit [Elgar]
Horn Concerto No 4, movements 2 and 3 [Mozart] (soloist: Ione Petch)
The Grenadiers [Waldteufel]
Swan Lake [Tchaikovsky]
(subsequently replaced by William Tell [Rossini])
INTERVAL
Nell Gwynn Dances [Edward German]
Pianoforte Solo (soloist: Rachel Anderson)
(subsequently replaced by Piano Concerto No 1, movements 1 and 2 [Mendelssohn]
London Every Day No 1 [Eric Coates]
The Last Spring [Grieg]
Pomp & Circumstance March No 1 [Elgar]
GOD SAVE THE QUEEN